GraphQL Subscriptions and WebSockets are related but not synonymous: WebSockets is a transport protocol that provides a persistent, bidirectional communication channel, while GraphQL Subscriptions is a GraphQL operation type that uses a transport (often WebSockets) to enable server-to-client real-time data streaming within the GraphQL schema .
WebSockets and GraphQL Subscriptions are fundamentally different concepts that work together. WebSockets is a low-level transport protocol that provides a persistent, bidirectional communication channel between a client and a server . GraphQL Subscriptions, on the other hand, is a GraphQL operation type (alongside Query and Mutation) that uses a transport—most commonly WebSockets—to deliver real-time data updates to clients within the structure of the GraphQL schema .
While WebSockets can be used for any real-time application, GraphQL Subscriptions is specifically the GraphQL feature that leverages a transport like WebSockets to implement real-time functionality. You can think of WebSockets as the underlying "plumbing" and GraphQL Subscriptions as the GraphQL-native "interface" that defines what real-time data clients can subscribe to and how that data is structured .
GraphQL Subscriptions can be implemented over various transports, each with distinct characteristics. The table below compares the primary transport options: WebSockets, Server-Sent Events (SSE), and HTTP Callbacks.
Full-Duplex vs. Half-Duplex: WebSockets are full-duplex, allowing both client and server to initiate communication. SSE is half-duplex—only the server can send messages to the client . HTTP Callbacks are also half-duplex, with the server "calling back" to the router when data is available .
Connection Model: WebSockets maintain a persistent, long-lived connection for each client. SSE uses a long-lived HTTP connection. HTTP Callbacks do not maintain a persistent connection; instead, the server checks in periodically or when data is available .
Firewall Compatibility: SSE generally has better compatibility with firewalls since it uses standard HTTP. WebSockets may face issues with some firewalls and proxy servers .
GraphQL Support: WebSockets has been the traditional default for GraphQL subscriptions and is supported by most server implementations (graphql-ws protocol). SSE is also supported via libraries like graphql-sse. HTTP Callbacks are a newer approach designed for federated GraphQL architectures .
Communication Direction: WebSockets are bidirectional; SSE and HTTP Callbacks are unidirectional (server to client).
State Management: WebSockets maintain a persistent stateful connection. HTTP Callbacks are stateless, making them more suitable for serverless environments .
Resource Usage: WebSockets consume significant memory per connection. HTTP Callbacks and SSE are generally more resource-efficient .
Scalability: HTTP Callbacks and SSE scale more easily than WebSockets, which require maintaining many open connections .
- https://hygraph.com/learn/graphql/subscriptions
- https://www.apollographql.com/blog/reduce-real-time-cloud-spend-with-federated-subscriptions-support-for-http-callbacks
- https://the-guild.dev/graphql/yoga-server/tutorial/advanced/02-subscriptions
- https://github.com/ChilliCream/graphql-platform/blob/main/website/src/docs/hotchocolate/v13/defining-a-schema/subscriptions.md